Classic Journalism: Robert Christgau, The Dean of Rock Criticism

Thursday, December 11th, 2008

photo by Fred McDarrah

The first time I read Robert Christgau’s review, “Trying to Understand the Eagles,” I was 13 years-old, sitting on my great-grandaunt’s living room couch in Minneapolis. Originally published in Newsday in 1972 and reprinted in his first book, 1973’s Any Old Way You Choose It, the piece is essentially the reason I became a rock critic.

The essay begins as a relatively evenhanded dissection of the Eagles. It was a model for the way Christgau—credited with being one of the creators of rock criticism—would write in the decades to come. He always takes his subject’s signifiers seriously—thinking about what they really mean. He knew early on that the Eagles’ streamlined popcraft had real skill in it, and he also smelled the noticeably swollen egos of the early-’70s rock stars. The way Christgau connects their debut album to the aftermath of the ’60s dream’s fallout is instructive, too: folks who loathe the Eagles today tend to do so because the band’s tendency to be sappy and nostalgic only got worse. Which, as it turns out, is where Christgau thought they might be headed.

But the line that provided the revelation, the one that made me change my thinking to “I want to do that,” instead of, “It might be fun to do that,” is one of the greatest literary switcheroos in music criticism. It’s a sentence so elegant and simple, and so perfectly deadpan, that it inspired many of my peers in the field to become rock critics, as well. See if you can spot it.


“Trying to Understand the Eagles.”

Michaelangelo Matos is the author of Sign ‘O’ the Times Continuum, 2004) and has contributed to many magazines, newspapers, websites, and anthologies. He has a personal blog, Schmusic at http://m-matos.blogspot.com/. He lives in Seattle and is moving to New York again (for love, not money) in 2009.

The Green Report: Obama’s Greenies

Thursday, December 11th, 2008

Browner, Chu, Jackson

Just what we need, a new energy and environmental team. According to Wednesday’s New York Times, Obama’s transition officials said he has selected several key members of this team. For the Secretary of Energy position, Obama has chosen Nobel Prize-winning physicist, Stephen Chu, who also serves as the director of the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. And officials stated he will chose Los Angeles’ deputy mayor for energy and environment, Nancy Sutley, to lead the White House Council on Environmental Quality. Obama’s officials sound as though his selections for head of the Environmental Protection Agency and climate czar are a bit less certain. He has supposedly selected Lisa P. Jackson, New Jersey’s former commissioner of Environmental Protection. If confirmed, Jackson would be the first African American to head the U.S. E.P.A.

And it appears as though Obama’s going to give the top White House position on climate and energy policy to President Bill Clinton’s E.P.A. administrator, Carol M. Browner. If Obama selects Browner, who was an Al Gore follower, she is assumed to have support from several key members of Congress like Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi, and Representative “Henry A. Waxman of California, who will be the new chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, and Senator Barbara Boxer of California, who is returning as chairwoman of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee.” Hopefully, Obama’s choices will work out well because he has a tough road ahead to meet his goal of reducing global warming emissions and creating more “green” jobs.

Can you believe there are E.P.A. fugitives? Well, believe it! The Environmental Protection Agency has a web site that list all of the fugitives sought by its Criminal Investigation Division. Are you wondering what gets you on the environmental bad guys list? The site gives a case summary and how to report information about them in case you see one. It’s like America’s Most Wanted for environmental criminals. (I can hear the theme song playing. “Whatcha gonna do when they come for you? Bad Boys. Bad Boys.”) Surprisingly, Bush and members of his administration are not listed.

This report wouldn’t be complete without green gifts for the holidays. CleanTechnica has a list of the 8 Best Green Gadget Gifts. Some of the items include a power strip that tells you the energy efficiency of your appliances with a numerical reading, and a wind-powered electronics charger. These are just a few of the gifts. Pretty cool stuff for the greenie in your life.

Riffs&Revolutions: Granny’s Grits

Thursday, December 11th, 2008

http://imagecache2.allposters.com/images/pic/OHIO/30575~Kiss-My-Grits-Posters.jpg

Being raised by both my mother and grandmother had its advantages. Thinking back to life uptown during my 1970s wonder years, one of the first thoughts that come to mind is the food that was constantly cooking on our old stove.

Dark as mahogany, grandma came from Harrisonburg, Virginia; born into a family of country chefs who dwelled in the Negro neighborhood known as New Town (her own grandmother’s fresh biscuits and jelly were legendary), she seemed to think it was a sin if something wasn’t frying, broiling, simmering, boiling, baking or in the process of cooling off.

“Grandma cooks and mommy heats up,” I once told one of my mother’s friends. Yet, since grandma worked in a factory in New Jersey and was out of the flat before I awoke, Sunday mornings was the only time she made a full breakfast. Returning home from nine o’clock mass at St. Catherine of Genoa, where I was an altar-boy, the hearty smell of eggs, bacon, sausages and grits met me at the front door.

Though I’m not sure what was on my mind, I always said I didn’t want any grits. Maybe it was the way they looked or the way grits hardened in the pot when they were cold, but I wasn’t feeling them. “Boy don’t know what he missing, Mary,” grandma’s boyfriend Joe said and laughed. Staring at his plate, a yellow river of yolk from his over-easy eggs pooled into the grits.

“Well, if he don’t want’em, I can’t force him,” she replied. Although I could hear in her voice that my rejection of the grits was a slight betrayal to her, I refused to relent. In the same way that I (at the time) detested chicken and dumplings and pig feet, I spent my entire childhood gritless. A few years later, when I was fourteen, me, mom and baby brother moved to Baltimore. I stayed in the City of Poe graduating from high school. Then, in the August of ’81, I returned to Harlem and to my grandma’s soulful kitchen.

Although it was just the two of us living there, grandma still cooked as though an army was coming. Yet, as a freshman at Long Island University in Brooklyn, I became popular because I often brought home hungry friends for Sunday dinner. “Now make sure you get enough,” she said sweetly, her dark hands holding the spoon tightly as she put more food on our plates.

Afterwards, grandma wrapped up the food in heavy aluminum foil and insisted my friend took some grub back to the dorm. I recall once asking if she had her recipes written down, but she just laughed. “I don’t need any recipes,” she said proudly, pointing to her temple. “I got them all up here.”

To this day, I can’t quite explain what got me eating grits; perhaps, as an adult, they became less gross or I just got more curious about what was such the big deal. I had put a little salt, butter and cheese on them, and shoved them in the mouth.

Expecting the worse, I was blown away by the taste. I thought about Joe, who had died years before, teasing me at Sunday breakfast. It was at that moment that my tongue began to do the happy dance. “Not you eating grits,” grandma blurted proudly that summer Sunday morning as we sat at the faux-wood kitchen table.

Fourteen years after grandma’s death on March 8, 1994, I still eat grits on Sunday mornings whenever possible; and with each massive forkful, I think about grandma.

This post originally appeared on Michael Gonzales’s blog.

Amuse Bouche: LOLHAN Makes Lindsay Lohan Fun Again

Thursday, December 11th, 2008

Ever since Lindsay Lohan started dating Samantha Ronson, she’s been kind of boring. Sure, every now and then, they have some rumored lovers squabble over whether or not Lilo can touch some random manho’s peen, but for the most part she hasn’t done anything interesting in a long, long time. No “Look ma, no panties” flashes, no nip slips, no getting arrested for driving too fast and having things in your pockets, no passed out drunk pictures, no rehab bikini shots. NOTHING.

It’s a fucking desert over here. I’m dying. (ED note—When will Lourdes and Frances Bean step up and put an end to this dry spell?)

The only thing left is to take current and former pictures of Lohan and give her ‘tarded LOLCATz speak captions.

Amuse Bouche: Laid Off Journos Form All-Important Drinking Club

Thursday, December 11th, 2008

http://i56.photobucket.com/albums/g175/xdescendx/drunk3.jpg

Introducing ASSME, The American Society of Shitcanned Media Elites. (Aha! So you do think you’re elite! Sarah Palin is coming!) Started by a unnamed group of people, but suspiciously emailed to me by ex-Radar executive editor Aaron Gell (full-disclosure: he’s my former ed there), under “Our Mission, it says: “Through time-tested methods (alcohol, social interaction), we seek to sustain and inspire this beleaguered professional subclass.”

Under events, they implore: “One of the most challenging aspects of the often painful transition from gainful employment to sitting home watching The View is social isolation, with the attendant lethargy, poor grooming and weight gain (the so-called “Freelance Fifteen”). Don’t be a victim.”

New Yorkers can join ASSME by showing up to their party December 17 (the flyer says: “Still employed? You’re buying the first round!”

Besides, as they say: “Drinking was all we had left.”

http://students.cs.byu.edu/~ericman/spencer/pics/spencer/spencer%20drunk.jpg
http://assme.org