waterboarding

McCain’s Straight Talk Express Needed on Torture

Thursday, September 11th, 2008

Where does former Prisoner of War John McCain really stand on the issue of torture? Is the Republican presidential candidate in favor of the use of torture or against it?

When he was recently asked by Marie Claire magazine which celebrity he identifies with most, McCain said:

“Kiefer Sutherland. [laughs, imitates a voice from the show 24] ‘It’s Jack Bauer.’ We have a lot in common because he escapes all the time.”

However, when reminded of Jack Bauer’s use of torture in the show, McCain does a Hollywood Retake. He says:

Yeah, that’s right. That’s where Jack and I disagree. He believes in torture, but I don’t. He says, “Tell me where the weapons are.” The person says, “I won’t.” Bam! “OK, I’ll tell.”

I’m not sure which is more disconcerting. McCain’s choice of Jack Bauer from 24 as the character he most identifies with. The fact that policymakers like McCain are actually influenced by fictional television characters. (Who said TV doesn’t affect the viewers?) Or maybe McCain’s choice of Bauer was a Freudian slip?

Yet…McCain’s record on torture belies another story. According to his voting record, McCain voted against a bill banning the use of waterboarding by the CIA. And after the bill passed, he asked Bush to veto it.

So, let’s ask the question again. Is McCain for or against torture? Here is a little refresher of McCain’s stance on torture back in February 2008, courtesy of MSNBC’s Keith Olbermann.

This video was embedded using the YouTuber plugin by Roy Tanck. Adobe Flash Player is required to view the video.

While you were voting

Friday, February 8th, 2008

waterboarding2.jpg

While you were voting, phone banking, mastering delegate math or dodging a killer tornado in the Midwest, the Bush administration was busy finally admitting to and condoning torture.

CIA Director Michael Hayden chose stormy distracting Super Tuesday to concede for the record that the CIA used waterboarding to extract information from three Al Qaeda suspects. “In the most detailed public comments on a CIA program that had been shrouded in secrecy for years, Hayden said the agency had used simulated drowning to extract crucial information from terrorism suspects in 2002 and 2003,” reported The Los Angeles Times.

A day later, as campaign pundits tracked the delegate count, the Bush administration announced that waterboarding, which has been the subject of attorney general hearings and presidential debates, has been made legal. The L.A. Times quoted White House spokesman Tony Fratto saying waterboarding is legal and could be used “under certain circumstances.”

(more…)

The tough-guy-coward platform

Friday, October 26th, 2007

bauerweeps.jpg

Yesterday McCain called out Giuliani for equivocating on waterboarding, making the mayor seem exactly like the mayor— that is, like someone who will happily prattle on no matter how head fogged by politics and ideology and wishful thinking he may be on a topic.

McCain has served in the military and has, alone among the candidates, been tortured, being held in captivity in a Vietnamese prison for five long damned years. He’s the only Republican candidate for president who speaks with any kind of authority on the matter. The rest apparently believe talking Hollywood BS about torturing terrorist suspects makes them sound tough, which is pathetic, I mean the very idea that they would prefer to sound like Jack Bauer rather than John McCain. Think about that for a minute.

“All I can say is that waterboarding was used in the Spanish Inquisition, in Pol Pot’s genocide in Cambodia, and reportedly against protesting monks in Burma today,” said McCain, deadpan. If Giuliani is at all “unsure” whether waterboarding constitutes torture, he continued, then the tough guy / War on Terror candidate simply doesn’t know what waterboarding is: “It’s not a complicated procedure. It’s torture.”

(more…)